Machine and storage windows full of stock

Probably Stolen Underground Exchange: Every Sawyer Trade and How It Works

How Sawyer’s Underground Exchange works in Probably Stolen: every permanent and weekly trade, the Smuggler’s Bay upgrade, why your trade failed, and how to unlock it early.

Light spoilersUpdated Sourced from a published guide on version 100-REV3 and player reports

Quick answer

Sawyer opens the exchange on Day 25. Leave the input items in your store trash can before you sleep, keep the Janitorial Service active, and collect the reward the next morning. Each trade works once a night, and it also raises your Black Market reputation.

On this page

How to unlock it

Sawyer arrives on Day 25 and leaves the Underground Exchange Directive on the ledge. The Sawyer's Crew perk unlocks it from Day 1, and the Fence start has it straight away.

How a trade works

  1. Put the input items in your store's trash can before you sleep.
  2. Keep the Janitorial Service active. Without it, no trade happens.
  3. Collect the reward from the trash can the next morning.

You can run several different trades in one night if the can holds everything, but each trade only works once a night.

Why your trade failed

Check that Janitorial was on and that the can wasn't full. A full can forfeits the reward, and anything not used in a trade is thrown out as garbage. At -40 Black Market reputation you're blacklisted from the exchange.

Permanent trades

Put inGet backNotes
3 Water Filters (any condition)1 new Water FilterGood for used filters
Any 2 modules1 random moduleNever the same type as the input
2 Vials of Dream DustRandom legal goodsHigher purity gives more
1 Disposable Keycard (Command)2 random keycardsSecurity, Engineering or Medical
2 Poison1 Energy CellCharge depends on the poisons' value, up to 100
2 AmmunitionAt least 2 food itemsContraband ammo gives more food
Smuggler's Bay + 8 Oxymore InjectorsSmuggler's Bay (Modified)Value rises from 250 to 400

The module trade usually gives Performance, Efficiency or Quality modules. Overclock, Eco and Refinement are less common, and the Neural Core Module is extremely rare.

One player tried the Smuggler's Bay trade and got an empty bay back the next day, so check the bay really was modified before you repeat it.

Weekly promotional trades

Three of seven promotional trades are picked each week, and the selection resets on Monday. Your Monday Nightly Report announces the change.

Put inGet back
4 Vials of Dream DustMedical goods, better at higher purity
4 Disposable Keycards (Medical)Medical Bay Supply Crate
4 Disposable Keycards (Engineering)Engineering Foundry Supply Crate
3 Disposable Keycards (Security)Security Department Supply Crate
Any 5 SeedsA fully charged Energy Cell
1 Scavenger's TokenBlack Market reputation
2 Oxymore InjectorsA Genuine Immunivax Injector

Dream Dust at 99% purity or better returns Synaprest Injectors and Bags of "Blue Blood". Low purity returns only two bandages.

Sources

  1. Every Underground Exchange trade — AllThings.How, 2026-10
  2. Discussion: Smuggler’s Bay upgrade came back empty — Steam Community, 2026-10-31

Spotted an error?

Games get patched and early reports can be wrong. Send a correction with a source link. Our editorial policy explains how pages are checked.

Continue your journey

Related guides